Understanding the Imposter Within: Personality Types and Coping Strategies

“Oh Tim, I’ve just had the most ghastly weekend because I felt so unworthy.” This surprising statement was made by Paul Nurse, a Nobel Prize winner, to his fellow laureate, Tim Hunt. It was just a few weeks after they both received the prestigious award. This reaction is not unusual, even among the most successful individuals. Winning a Nobel Prize often leads to intense soul-searching. Many laureates, when reflecting on their careers, ask themselves, “Why me?”. This story perfectly illustrates the Imposter Phenomenon (IP), commonly known as Imposter Syndrome, where high-achieving individuals doubt their accomplishments and fear being exposed as frauds.

In this blog series, we will explore this intriguing and often paralysing experience. We’ll delve into the science and psychology behind it, discuss its symptoms, and provide practical strategies for overcoming it. Our approach is straightforward: the more you understand something, the better equipped you are to deal with it. This principle is particularly true when addressing mental health issues and personal dilemmas. So, let’s embark on this journey of understanding and empowerment.

What is imposter syndrome:

Imposter Syndrome, also known as the Imposter Phenomenon, is a psychological experience where individuals doubt their accomplishments and have an internalized fear of being exposed as a fraud. Despite evident success, people experiencing Imposter Syndrome believe their achievements are not due to their skills or efforts but rather to luck, chance, or even deception. This can lead to chronic feelings of self-doubt, anxiety, and the fear that they will be "found out" at any moment.
The concept of Imposter Syndrome was first identified by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes in the 1970s.
Here is a real-life example to better understand it.

Meet Emily, a successful marketing manager
Emily is a highly successful marketing manager at a large company. She has led several successful campaigns and received praise from her colleagues and bosses. Despite her accomplishments, Emily constantly feels like she's "faking it" and worries that one day her coworkers will discover that she’s not as competent as they think. When she receives positive feedback, she often attributes it to luck or help from her team, rather than recognizing her hard work and talent. Even though she’s well-qualified, Emily hesitates to apply for promotions because she fears she doesn’t really deserve them.

Explaining imposter syndrome to a 5 year old:
Imagine you're at a birthday party, and you've just won a big trophy for being really good at a game. Everyone is clapping and telling you how great you are. But instead of feeling happy, you feel like you don't deserve it. You think, "Maybe I just got lucky," or "What if everyone finds out I'm not really that good?"
That's a bit like what Imposter Syndrome is. It's when people feel like they aren't as smart or talented as other people think they are, even when they've done really good things. They might worry that one day someone will find out they're "pretending."

The experience of imposter syndrome:

When you experience imposter syndrome, you often find yourself attributing your successes to temporary factors such as luck, effort, or the favor of others, rather than your own abilities. This mindset is accompanied by a constant fear of being exposed as a fraud, making it hard to truly internalize and appreciate your own accomplishments.

This struggle can manifest in several ways:

Repetitive negative self-talk: You might frequently criticize yourself and question your abilities, doubting whether you deserve your achievements.
Feeling not good enough: No matter what you accomplish, there’s a lingering sense that you’re not measuring up or that you’re falling short.
Difficulty accepting praise: Compliments and recognition may feel uncomfortable or unwarranted, and you struggle to believe they are deserved.
Focusing on mistakes: You may become obsessed with your errors and failures, often over-emphasizing their importance and letting them overshadow your successes.
Anxiety about being found out: There’s a persistent worry that you’ll be discovered as a fraud, which can create overwhelming stress and anxiety.

And the impact of these feelings and thoughts can lead to:

Unrealistically high standards: You might set excessively high expectations for yourself and feel inadequate if you don’t meet them.
Perfectionism: This drive for perfection can result in procrastination or spending excessive time on tasks to ensure they are flawless.
Taking criticisms personally: You may internalize all flaws and criticisms, having trouble accepting any positive feedback.
Feeling like a fraud: This sense of fraudulence can lead to overworking, self-sabotage, avoiding opportunities, and procrastination, all of which further entrench your feelings of inadequacy.

The 4 Ps of imposter syndrome:

Let’s delve into the 4 Ps of Imposter Syndrome, a framework introduced by Clare Josa. These are four common behaviors that can reveal the presence of imposter syndrome, whether in ourselves or in those around us.

1.Perfectionism:
The first and most recognizable sign is perfectionism. This involves setting extremely high standards for yourself and dismissing any success as mere luck or a fluke. Some people are naturally perfectionistic, where everything must be flawless. For others, perfectionism surfaces as a way to cope with stress, burnout, or feelings of inadequacy. Signs include working longer hours, taking excessive time on tasks, second-guessing how others will react, and hesitating to make decisions due to fear of failure.

2. Procrastination:
This is more than just delaying tasks for trivial distractions. Procrastination here means avoiding the main task and instead focusing on less critical activities. A 2022 study highlighted that over 70% of those with imposter syndrome use procrastination as a frequent coping strategy. If you find yourself sidestepping important responsibilities, you’re in good company.

3. Project paralysis:
This occurs when you feel overwhelmed and unable to act, much like a deer caught in headlights. Instead of tackling a challenging task, you might ignore it or hope it will resolve itself. This avoidance often results in a last-minute scramble to meet deadlines, driven by stress and adrenaline, sometimes leading to all-nighters. This behavior widens the gap between where you are and where you want to be, exacerbating imposter syndrome.

4. People-pleasing:
This involves stretching yourself too thin, not setting appropriate boundaries, and trying too hard to make everyone happy. You might avoid negotiating for a fair salary, take on additional tasks despite being overwhelmed, or volunteer for things that aren’t part of your job. People-pleasers often do this to feel accepted and avoid rejection.

These 4 Ps—perfectionism, procrastination, project paralysis, and people-pleasing—reflect our automatic stress responses. They are driven by fear and the sense of being in danger, often operating beneath our conscious awareness. Recognising these behaviours is crucial for managing and overcoming imposter syndrome.

Do you have imposter syndrome?

If you've ever wondered whether you experience imposter syndrome, the Clance Imposter Phenomenon Scale can be a helpful tool. Developed by Dr. Pauline Rose Clance, this scale consists of 20 statements designed to measure the intensity of imposter feelings. Each statement is assessed on a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 means "not at all true" and 5 means "very true."

This scale can help you determine how strongly you experience imposter syndrome by evaluating your responses to statements such as “I often compare my ability to those around me and think they may be more intelligent than I am” or “I worry about my ability to succeed in the future even though I've done well in the past.” The higher your score, the more likely you are to experience imposter syndrome.
If you're curious to find out more, you can take the test yourself using this link.

5 types of imposter syndrome personalities:

Dr. Valerie Young’s research on Imposter Syndrome has identified five distinct types of personalities, each characterized by a unique focus and set of unrealistic standards. These personalities are often linked to feelings of inadequacy, self-doubt, and the constant fear of being exposed as a "fraud."

The perfectionist:

Relatable One-Liner: "If it's not perfect, it's a failure."

Focus on “How”: The Perfectionist is primarily concerned with how tasks are performed and the quality of the results.
Unrealistic Standards: They set excessively high standards for themselves and believe that anything less than perfect equals failure.

Fear of Flaws: Even a minor flaw in an otherwise stellar performance or achieving 99 out of 100 is perceived as a failure, leading to feelings of shame.

Emily the Perfectionist:

Background: Emily is a senior graphic designer at a prominent advertising agency. She graduated top of her class and is known for her meticulous attention to detail.
Characteristics: Emily sets extremely high standards for herself and often feels disappointed, even when her work is praised. She tends to focus on minor flaws and believes that anything less than perfect is a failure.
Behaviors: Emily spends extra hours tweaking her designs, often redoing work that others find exceptional. She avoids delegating tasks because she fears they won't meet her high standards.
Example Scenario: Emily recently completed a major campaign that was well-received by the client and her team. Despite the praise, she feels anxious about the small imperfections only she notices and worries she didn’t do a good enough job.

2. The expert:
Relatable one-liner: "If I can't answer every question, I'm a fraud."

Focus on “What” and “How Much”: The Expert measures competence based on the breadth and depth of knowledge.
Need for Knowledge: They feel they must know everything and view even minor gaps in knowledge as a failure.
Fear of Not Knowing: Not being able to answer a question or lacking information causes feelings of shame and inadequacy.

The expert: Sarah the knowledge seeker:

Background: Sarah is a marketing strategist with multiple degrees and certifications. She is constantly seeking new learning opportunities to expand her knowledge.
Characteristics: Sarah measures her worth by how much she knows. She fears being exposed as inexperienced or unknowledgeable and believes she must be an expert in every aspect of her field.
Behaviors: Sarah frequently enrolls in courses and attends seminars, sometimes over-preparing for tasks. She hesitates to apply for jobs or promotions unless she meets every qualification.
Example Scenario: Sarah was offered a leadership position at her company but turned it down because she felt she didn’t know enough about certain aspects of the role. Instead, she signed up for more courses to gain additional certifications.

3. The Soloist:
Relatable one-liner: "Asking for help means I'm not capable."

Focus on “Who”: The Soloist believes that tasks must be completed independently to demonstrate competence.
Self-Reliance: They feel that needing help or guidance is a sign of failure and evokes shame.
Fear of Dependency: Accepting assistance or collaborating with others is seen as a weakness.

The soloist: Maria the independent artist:

Background: Maria is a freelance graphic artist who prides herself on her independence. She has built a successful career by creating unique artwork for various clients without relying on others.
Characteristics:Maria feels that asking for help or collaborating with others would reveal her as an imposter. She believes she must complete all projects on her own to prove her skills.
Behaviors: Maria turns down opportunities to collaborate with other artists and avoids using assistants or interns. She often works alone late into the night, trying to manage every aspect of her projects herself.
Example Scenario: Maria was offered a chance to work on a high-profile art installation with a team of artists. Although she was excited, she declined because she felt working in a team would mean she couldn’t handle the project independently. She feared being exposed as inadequate if she couldn’t manage every detail herself.

4. The natural genius:
Relatable one-liner: "If I don't get it right on the first try, I'm a fraud."

Focus on “How” and “When”: The Natural Genius believes that competence is determined by the ease and speed of achieving success.
Effortless Success: They expect to master new skills quickly and without effort. Struggling or needing time to learn is perceived as a failure.
Fear of Struggle: Any difficulty in learning or inability to achieve instant success leads to feelings of inadequacy and shame.

The natural genius: Kevin the prodigy scientist:

Background: Kevin is a research scientist who gained attention early in his career for his groundbreaking work in biotechnology. He is used to mastering new concepts quickly and effortlessly.
Characteristics: Kevin believes he should understand everything immediately. When faced with a challenge, he doubts his abilities and feels like a fraud if he doesn’t grasp concepts instantly.
Behaviors: Kevin avoids tasks that don’t come easily to him. He becomes frustrated when he has to spend extra time understanding complex theories or experiments.
Example Scenario: Kevin was tasked with leading a research project involving a new technology he wasn’t familiar with. After struggling with the initial setup, he began questioning his competency. Instead of seeking help or further training, he considered abandoning the project because he felt he should already be an expert.

5. The Superhuman:
Relatable one-liner: "I must excel in every role I take on, or I am not good enough."

Focus on “How Many”: The Superhuman measures competence by how many roles they can juggle and excel in simultaneously.
Role Juggling: They believe they must excel in all areas of life, including work, family, friendships, and hobbies.
Fear of Falling Short: Any perceived failure in balancing these roles evokes shame, as they feel they should handle everything perfectly and effortlessly.

The Superwoman/Superman: Lisa the multi-tasking executive:

Background: Lisa is a high-ranking executive at a multinational corporation. She is known for her ability to manage complex projects while also balancing her roles as a mentor, mother, and board member of several charities.
Characteristics: Lisa believes she must excel in every aspect of her life to validate her worth. She constantly takes on more responsibilities to prove she can handle them all.
Behaviours: Lisa regularly works late into the night, attends all her children’s events, volunteers for extra projects at work, and participates in community service. She rarely takes time for herself and often sacrifices sleep to meet her commitments.
Example scenario: Lisa recently led her team to complete a successful merger and acquisition deal. Instead of taking a break to celebrate, she immediately volunteered to lead another project, signed up for a charity event, and helped her children with a school project. She feels she can’t slow down or else others might think she’s not capable or committed.

Strategies for managing different personality types:

Each personality type presents unique challenges and opportunities. Here’s how to navigate them effectively:

Perfectionist: embrace imperfection:

Progress over perfection: Recognize that aiming for perfection can hinder progress. Sometimes, "good enough" is all you need to move forward.
Allocate effort wisely: Not every task requires 100% effort. Prioritize where perfection is necessary and where it isn’t.
Acknowledge the impact on others: Understand that your pursuit of perfection can create stress for those around you.
Celebrate mistakes: View mistakes as learning opportunities and embrace the imperfections that come with growth.

Expert: Expand your knowledge base:

Multiple paths to expertise: Recognize that there are many ways to gain expertise, and they all contribute to your growth.
Stay curious: Remember that learning is a lifelong journey, with always more to discover.
Respect boundaries: Acknowledge your limits and avoid overextending yourself.
Leverage collective knowledge: You don’t need to have all the answers—rely on others' expertise when necessary.
Stay confident in uncertainty: Maintain confidence, even when you don’t have all the answers.

The Soloist: Collaborate for success:

Identify resources: Determine what you need before beginning a task, and don’t hesitate to seek help.
Value teamwork: Recognize that asking for support doesn’t undermine your competence; it enhances it.
Seek expertise: Don’t shy away from consulting those who know more in certain areas.
Smart execution over innovation: You don’t always need to break new ground—sometimes, building on existing work is the smartest move.

Natural Genius: Emphasize effort:

Value hard work over talent: Success is often the result of dedication rather than innate ability.
Reframe challenges: See obstacles as opportunities to grow, not as indicators of failure.
Practice patience: Understand that true mastery takes time and consistent effort, not just a quick win.

Superwoman/Superman/Student: Set boundaries:

Learn to say no: Setting boundaries is essential for preserving your energy and focus.
Delegate to empower: Sharing responsibilities not only lightens your load but also empowers others.
Focus on priorities: Eliminate non-essential tasks to concentrate on what truly matters.
Be mindful of expectations: Understand that striving to do it all can set unrealistic standards for yourself and others.

In the nutshell:
Here’s how to balance the strengths of your type with healthy adjustments:

Perfectionists can uphold high standards without guilt when perfection isn’t achieved.
Natural Geniuses can pursue excellence while recognizing the effort required to achieve it.
Experts should continue to value knowledge while accepting that it’s okay not to know everything.
The Soloists can take pride in their independence while acknowledging the benefits of collaboration.
Superhumans can strive for excellence across multiple areas while letting go of the need to do it all themselves.

We hope this blog has given you a deeper understanding of Imposter Syndrome—what it is, why it occurs, and how it can influence your life. Recognizing these feelings is the first step toward managing them effectively. If Imposter Syndrome is affecting your day-to-day well-being, remember that there are many psychological treatments available, including Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and other proven methods. Reaching out to a psychologist can provide the personalized support you might need.

For those who prefer a more accessible option, our AI-powered chatbot Stamina is designed to offer guidance similar to that of a real psychologist. It can suggest tailored coping strategies to help you navigate not just Imposter Syndrome, but a range of mental health challenges.

In the second part of this blog series, we explore a variety of actionable strategies to help you combat Imposter Syndrome. These activities are designed to empower you with practical tools for real change. We encourage you to take a look.

As we conclude, we want to leave you with a powerful reminder to embrace your imperfections and focus on progress over perfection:
"Ring the bells that still can ring, forget your perfect offering.
There is a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in."
— Leonard Cohen, Anthem

Try Stamina AI to deal with your imposter syndrome

Let's go!